January 01, 2006

Cancer and terrorism

John Quiggin at Crooked Timber takes another look at cancer as a metaphor for terrorism:

It struck me that, to make this metaphor exact we’d need:

• attacks on cancer researchers for seeking to ‘understand’ cancer

• even more attacks on anyone trying to find ‘root causes’ for cancer in the environment, such as exposure to tobacco smoke

• lengthy pieces pointing out that the only thing we need to know about cancer cells is that they are malignant

• more lengthy pieces pointing out that criticism of any kind of quack remedy marks the critic as “objectively pro-cancer”
Perhaps. Though, I’d add a couple more:
• lengthy articles from moral philosophers pointing out that cancer cells can't be held responsible for their malignancy

• numerous highly speculative papers from researchers suggesting that if cancer is left untreated it won’t spread